You got an offer. It came in lower than you expected — maybe a lot lower. Before you fire off a rejection or start venting to your agent about the nerve of some people, there’s a better move. How you respond to a lowball offer can shape the entire negotiation, and sellers who handle it well tend to walk away with better outcomes than the ones who take it personally.

This is one of the moments in selling a home when the right decision isn’t obvious, and the wrong one—driven by frustration or ego—quietly costs money.

What Actually Counts as a Lowball Offer

“Lowball” is a word sellers use a lot, and it covers a wide range. For most sellers, anything below asking price feels disrespectful — but that’s not quite how negotiations work in practice.

A genuine lowball is typically 10% or more below market value. An offer that comes in 3–5% below asking on a home that’s been priced correctly? That’s negotiation. Understanding the difference matters, because it changes how you respond.

The first thing to look at is whether the offer has any reason behind it. Did the buyer include comparable sales they’re citing? Are they flagging condition concerns or deferred maintenance? A low offer with logic attached tells you something about who you’re dealing with. A low offer with no explanation is either a test or a buyer who hasn’t done their homework — and your agent can usually figure out which one it is with a quick call to the buyer’s agent.

Also worth noting: the price on the offer is only part of the picture. A lowball with strong terms — a flexible closing date, solid financing, no contingencies, and a large earnest money deposit — can be worth more than a full-price offer loaded with requests. Read the whole offer before you react to the number.

The Emotional Part (Let’s Get It Out of the Way)

Most sellers feel something when a low offer lands. That’s normal. You’ve lived in the house, maintained it, put money into it. You know what it means to you.

The problem is that emotional reaction tends to produce one of two bad outcomes. Sellers either reject the offer outright — sometimes without even countering — or they respond with a counter so close to asking that it signals the conversation is over. Both moves leave money on the table.

Here’s what I’ve seen from sellers who negotiate well: they treat an offer as a starting position, not a verdict. The buyer’s first number tells you they’re interested. Your job is to find out where the deal actually lives, not to punish them for throwing out an aggressive opener.

If you reject without countering, you lose your leverage and hand the buyer the next move. A counter — even a firm one at or near asking — keeps you in the driver’s seat.

Your Options When a Low Offer Lands

You have three choices: accept, reject, or counter. In almost every case, counter.

Counter at or near your asking price. If the home is priced correctly and you’ve had reasonable market activity, this is a legitimate response. It signals confidence without slamming the door. The buyer now has to decide whether they want the house.

Counter at a middle number. If the buyer came in 10–15% below and you have some pricing flexibility, a counter that closes some of that gap signals good faith. This doesn’t mean splitting the difference evenly — it means finding the number that works for you, then holding it. Don’t chase the buyer all the way down.

Counter on terms instead of price. Sometimes a low offer is also packed with asks: help with closing costs, appliance credits, a long inspection window, repair requests. Countering on the terms rather than the price — or adjusting both — can shift the financial picture significantly without either side feeling like they gave up too much.

Ask your agent to make a call first. Before you respond at all, it can be worth having your agent call the buyer’s agent to understand the reasoning. You’re not asking for sympathy — you’re gathering information. Understanding why the buyer landed where they did can tell you whether there’s a real deal hiding underneath a rough opener.

When Walking Away Is the Right Call

Sometimes the right answer is no counter at all.

If the buyer anchors far below market value and their subsequent moves don’t reflect real motivation — small increments, slow responses, requests that multiply — at some point you’re not negotiating; you’re being strung along. Some buyers aren’t your buyers.

But before you walk, ask a harder question: what does the market tell you? If your home has been sitting for 30, 45, or 60 days with limited activity, a lowball offer may be carrying information you need to hear.

At Reside in Kansas City, I have this conversation with sellers more than most agents want to. If a home is priced correctly and marketed well, it doesn’t sit. When offers come in consistently below asking — or don’t come in at all — the price is usually part of the story. A real buyer showing up with an aggressive offer is better data than radio silence.

What Sellers in the KC Metro Specifically Get Wrong

North of the river, the market moves quickly when a home is priced and presented well. Buyers shopping in Liberty, Kearney, Smithville, Parkville, and Gladstone right now are looking at the same sold comps your listing agent is. They know what homes have sold for in the last 90 days. They can see when the price is stretched.

A lowball offer in that context isn’t always bad manners — sometimes it’s a buyer saying, “I want this house, but not at this price.” The sellers who get stuck are the ones who dig in on a number the market hasn’t validated. The sellers who move forward are the ones who can separate their emotional investment from the transaction.

If your home is well-prepared, accurately priced, and professionally listed, most of the offers you receive will start in a reasonable range. The lowball becomes less of a crisis and more of a negotiation you know how to handle.

Negotiation Doesn’t End at Accepted — It Continues Through Inspection

One more layer to understand: accepting an offer doesn’t end the negotiation process; it moves it into the inspection phase. Buyers who come in low and then find condition issues during the inspection will often use those findings as a second round of leverage.

This is part of why preparation matters. A home that’s been thoughtfully maintained, honestly priced, and presented cleanly generates higher starting offers and negotiates more smoothly through inspection. There are fewer surprises on both sides, and fewer opportunities for the buyer to use the inspection report as a second pricing conversation.

If you’re thinking about selling — even if it’s a year or two out — the best place to start is an honest conversation about what your home would likely bring in today’s market and what, if anything, would change that number.

The Real Takeaway

A lowball offer can feel like the worst moment of selling a home. Usually, it isn’t. The sellers who get the most frustrated are the ones who take it personally. The ones who stay even-keeled — and stay at the table — tend to close at better prices.

Your home is worth what a ready, willing, and able buyer will pay. The job during negotiation is to find that number, not to win an argument.

─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

Jarred Donalson is a Kansas City real estate agent with Reside in Kansas City, specializing in the north-of-the-river KC metro. He works with buyers and sellers in Liberty, Kearney, Smithville, Parkville, Gladstone, and surrounding communities. Learn more at resideinkc.com.